Advanced Search

Who’s the Doctor?


Question:

In Exodus 15:26 it says "I am the Lord that heals you." Does going to a doctor contradict this? Thank you.



AskTheRabbi.org answered:

I have a story for you: A man swept away by a flood sees two guys approach in a rowboat. "Hop in!" they shout. "No, thanks," he says, "God will save me." Next, a tugboat passes by. "Climb aboard," calls the captain. Again he refuses. "God will save me," he says. Then the Coast Guard sends a helicopter but he refuses to board, giving the same reason. Finally, he drowns.

Up in Heaven, an angel asks why he refused help. "I wanted to rely on God alone," he replies. "Idiot!" says the angel. "Who do you think sent you the rowboat, the tugboat and the helicopter?"

God acts through the guise of doctors and medicine, just as He acts through the guise of employers to provide us with a living. Would your friends refuse to take money from their bosses, saying they'll get it directly from God? I think not. Do they eat food, or do they wait for God to miraculously inject their bloodstream with nourishing vitamins, minerals, fats and carbohydrates?

The Torah (Bible) gives explicit permission to engage in healing: If one person strikes another person, the verse says that the attacker "shall pay for his unemployment and for his medical expenses." (Exodus 21:19)

Our task is to exert the effort and then to recognize that ultimately it is God who heals. While seeking proper medical attention, a sick person simultaneously engages in prayer, good deeds, and introspection. We don't accept prayer as "a last resort" - it's a "first resort," along with medicine and the doctor.


Similar Questions
God > In Everyday Life
The Rainbow Reminder
Jewish Obligation?
Jewish Faith
Who and Where is God?
Book of Cures
“Love” and “Fear” of God
A Sabbatical for the Land
Reaction to Terror
A Moral Dilemma
The Russian Meteorite: a “Natural” Phenomenon?
All for the Best
Facing Terror in Israel
Miracle Maker
Israel – The Holy Land
Love on Demand
And Let Us Say “Amen”
Being a Good Jew
“Mazel Tov” & Energy from Above
Why Don’t I See Any Miracles?
The Fear Factor
A Cure for the Incurable
Thank God
Population Explosion
Changing My Appearance
Hallelujah
God’s “Will”
Branches of a Jewish Government
Best Friends Forever
Who Needs Whom?
My Very First Words
Tragedy and Faith in God
Miracles
“No Pain, No Gain”
Divine Justice
A Blessing on Your Head
Why Do Good People Suffer?
The Nepal Earthquake
Why Bring a Shlamim Sacrifice?
Good Intentions and Good Results
Miscellaneous > Activities
"Fixing the World"
Having Guns and Self Defense
Guns and Self Defense
Travel with Prayer Book
Eishet Chayil
Art
Dolls and Idols
Materialism
Whining and Dining (“Kosher” Restaurant Review)
Environmental Protection
Stepping on Star of David
Holiday Zemirot
The Healing Visit
Live Long and Prosper
All for the Best
The Jewish Vote
Powerball & Divine Providence
Recreation and Concentration
Kindness Unlimited — the “Gemach” System
Guns for Self-Defense
Punishment for Theft
Old Tallit
Can I Really Make a Difference?
Gateways Retreats
My Professor the Plumber
Drugs in Judaism
Abra Cadabra – Judaism and Magic
JWalking
A Life of Measured Pleasure
Yankee's Fan
Helping a Friend
Backward Yarmulke
Hypnotherapy for Weight Loss
Awakening Ritual
Study Buddy
A Carpet Caper
Close to Death
How to Become a Rabbi
When You Wish Upon a Well
Prayers and Blessings > Personal
Praying and Sadness
Blessing After Danger
Blessing for Headache
Doctor's Prayer
Long Distance Relationship
Traveler's Prayer
Desire to Pray
Nag, Kvetch and Change
Praying to have Children
Oh No! The First Day of School…
The Healing Visit
All for the Best
Prayer to find Lost Object
Tazddik's Blessing
Dealing with Death
A Prayer for Safe Travel
Post-Peril Praise
Is Anyone Listening?
“Prayer Force One”
Blessing after Danger
Chatan Reciting Sheva Brachot
A Good Time
Accepting My Prayer
HaGomel Prayer
A Prayer for the Kidnapped
Prayer for Lost Object
Birthday Blessings
Open for Business
Suffering Sick Person
Prayer for Health
Special Blessing for the Hosts
Birthdays and Prayer
Prayer for Pet
Sparkling Wine
Should I Say the Hagomel Blessing?
Mitzvot > Is This Permitted?
Traffic Safety
Hypnotism
Communal Property
Using Porcine Products
Feeding Pets
Shatnez – Wool and Linen
Acting on Astrological Advice
Donating and Selling Blood
Tattoo Taboo
Musical Instruments on Shabbat
Organ Donation
Kangaroo Shoes
Electric Shabbat Lights
Killing Insects
Cleaning Gravestones
To Compete or Not?
Forbidden Fabrics?
Riding a Tricycle
Collection Agency
Whining and Dining (“Kosher” Restaurant Review)
Pidyon HaBen at Night?
Touching Trees During Shemita
Red String and Hamsa
Winning by a Nose
Guns for Self-Defense
“Do Not Kill”– a Correct Translation?
Tallit
Cutting Nails
Bark Mitzvah
I Need it Like a Hole in the Head
Speech Therapy
Stock Transactions and Shabbat
Kilayim
Heating Pizza on Shabbat
Only Wine?
JWalking
The Census and Kosher Counting
Bible Disposal
A Symbol from Mt. Sinai
Eiruv
Reading Glasses
Backward Yarmulke
Tallit and Tzitzit in Bathroom
The Golden Ticket
Yom Tov Candles
Getting Drunk
Jonah and Suicide
A Medical Tattoo
Torah and Modern Communication Devices
Are Birthday Celebrations Permitted?
Blessings and Rabbi Photos
Using Ma’aser Money
“Eyes Only”
Abortion
Freedom of Speech
Have a question?
 
Gateways - Your Key to Jewish Continuity

AskTheRabbi.org is a service of the Gateways Organization © 2025
Technical problems? Please contact the AskTheRabbi Support team