Advanced Search

Nag, Kvetch and Change


Question:

My question is about prayer. How can my prayer work if God knows what is good for me and has plans for me anyway? If I nag and kvetch to God about what I want does it really change anything?

 



AskTheRabbi.org answered:

Yes, it can change you and therefore can change God's "decision" about what is good for you. Prayer is not a way of nagging God until He changes His mind about our fate. Rather, it is a means of changing ourselves. The order of the prayers serves to reinforce this idea even before we begin. The Talmudic Sages directed people to first engage in praise of God and only afterwards to request help from Him. When we begin by praising God, we remind ourselves of Whom exactly we are praying to and what prayer is meant to achieve. We then continue with our request, understanding that prayer is more than an eloquent kvetch.

Prayer instills a state of rest and tranquility, because as the individual prays, he increases his awareness that everything is in the hands of God. It is for this reason that our central prayer, the Amidah”

Internalizing this concept enables a person to feel less anxious, more secure and tranquil, no matter what challenges are encountered. Clearly, we should not be jellyfish flowing with the tides of life without exerting effort or trying to change direction. Nor is the positive aspect of every circumstance always obvious to us. On the other hand, we should realize that whatever may happen, we are in good hands.

 

 


Similar Questions
Prayers and Blessings > Rationale
Why Say Blessings?
Boredom
Prayer and Self-Evaluation
Dance: The Hidden Language of the Soul
Ark Direction in Synagogue
Income and Wealth
The “Shema”
Meaning of the Word "Bless"
The Purpose of Prayer
100 Blessings
What is a Minyan?
Shalom Aleichem
Divider at Western Wall
Shukling
Exercise and Blessing
Which Language to Pray In
Amen - Origins and Meaning
Minyan - A Group of Ten Men
Why Say Kaddish?
Meaning of Bless You
The Language of Prayer
Shakesprayer
And Let Us Say “Amen”
A Kosher (Golf) Course Blessing
The Wall that Unites
Why Say Blessings?
Inauguration Prayer of King Solomon
“Prayer Force One”
Tallit at Night?
HaGomel Prayer
Over-the-Counter Tranquility
Kaddish
The “Bathroom Blessing”
Swaying and Praying
A Blessing on Your Head
In the Beginning
Synagogue Symmetry
Prayers and Blessings > Personal
Praying and Sadness
Blessing After Danger
Blessing for Headache
Doctor's Prayer
Long Distance Relationship
Traveler's Prayer
Desire to Pray
Praying to have Children
Oh No! The First Day of School…
The Healing Visit
All for the Best
Prayer to find Lost Object
Tazddik's Blessing
Dealing with Death
A Prayer for Safe Travel
Post-Peril Praise
Is Anyone Listening?
“Prayer Force One”
Who’s the Doctor?
Blessing after Danger
Chatan Reciting Sheva Brachot
A Good Time
Accepting My Prayer
HaGomel Prayer
A Prayer for the Kidnapped
Prayer for Lost Object
Birthday Blessings
Open for Business
Suffering Sick Person
Prayer for Health
Special Blessing for the Hosts
Birthdays and Prayer
Prayer for Pet
Sparkling Wine
Should I Say the Hagomel Blessing?
Have a question?
 
Gateways - Your Key to Jewish Continuity

AskTheRabbi.org is a service of the Gateways Organization © 2024
Technical problems? Please contact the AskTheRabbi Support team