Advanced Search

Bon Voyage


Question:

A teacher mentioned that there’s a Jewish teaching that “the day of death is better than the day of birth”. Is that really true? It seems to me like it should be the opposite.



AskTheRabbi.org answered:

Yes it’s true. The verse states that “a good name is better than good oil, and the day of death than the day of one's birth.” (Kohelet - Ecclesiastes7:1)

The Sages compare life to a ship that is going out to sea. When the ship leaves port for the first time people throw streamers, a band plays and a bottle of champagne is broken on the ship’s bow. When the ship returns to port, there is no band and no streamers; only passport control and customs officers await it. In fact, it would be more appropriate to pray when a ship embarks because we do not know what will happen to it on its journey. The time to celebrate is when it returns in peace. Human emotion being what it is, we do not see life and death as a journey. We celebrate a new life and new potential and cry for our loss when a loved one dies. When, however, we consider all the good that the person achieved in his or her lifetime, our mourning is tempered by the knowledge that the ship has returned safely to its homeport.

In reality, the beginning of life should be a time of fear and trepidation, much more so than the end. At life’s beginning, everything is uncertain. We do not know if the soul will succeed in realizing its potential or fall short. At the end of a good life we know that the soul has gone back to its Creator – that it has achieved a tremendous amount while on this earth – but has now retuned to the place it truly desires to be.


Similar Questions
Life Cycle > Death and Mourning
120
Funeral Etiquette
Yahrzeit Date
Getting Married at Funeral Home
Wreaths on Graves
What is Sitting Shiva?
Kaddish for a Friend
Unfortunate Family Event
Jewish Cemetery
A Day to Remember
Parent Requesting Cremation
Burial and Cremation
Kaddish
How Long is Kaddish Said?
Cremation (2)
Reincarnation
Miscarriages
Euthanasia
What Happens After Death?
Tattoo and Burial
Tattoo Taboo
Why Say Kaddish?
Honoring a Parent
Sitting Shiva for a Baby
Learning the Laws of Mourning for Someone Who is Still Alive
Organ Donation
Jewish Cemetary
Longevity Limits
Visiting Gravesite
Explaining Death to a Child
Cleaning Gravestones
Visiting a Mourner
Quality of Life
When does Sitting Shiva End?
The “Kaddish” Prayer
Who Says Kaddish, How Long?
Sitting Shiva for Half Sibling
Dealing with Death
Travelling for Yahrzeit
Making a Monument
Of Blessed Memory
Perpetuating a Loved One
Mourner Leading Prayer Services
A Letter to Beyond
Cremation
The Last Day of Mourning
Jewish Burial
Attending Engagement During Mourning
My Child's Wedding During Mourning
Expressing Condolences
Tombstone Date
Covering Mirrors During Week of Mourning
Another World: More Than Meets the Eye
Unveiling
Don’t Pass the Shovel
The Comforting Visit
Close to Death
Placing Stones on Graves
A Reality Check
Services in a House of Mourning
The More Important Mitzvah
Where Do We Go When We Die?
Philosophy > People
Down Syndrome
Modesty
Judging Others
Changing My Appearance
Family Size
Loving Someone You Don’t “Like”
Interrupting
"Silver Lining"
Personal Dignity
Same or Different
Are Men and Women Equals?
Which is the Correct Name
Chauvinist
Judaism & Women’s Spiritual Superiority
Three Divisions
Being Jewish?
Orthodox Jew
Friends
Pursuit of Peace
Soul
A Day to Remember
You Saved It? You Bought It!
Sin to be Tricked?
Feeling Hurt
Woman of Valor
Longevity Limits
Nations
The Merchant of Vegas
I-Sight
To Forgive is Divine
Our Code of Honor
Judge Me Not
Responding to Insults
All in the Family
The Healing Visit
Lighting the Way
Slow and Steady Wins the Race
Testing the Waters
Recreation and Concentration
Eat, Drink, Be Merry, Tomorrow We Live
Long Lives
Matrilineal Descent
Of Blessed Memory
Silence
Jewish Education
The Human Soul
Tribes
Racism
Praying for National Unity
Was I Really “Born This Way”?
A Life of Measured Pleasure
Population Explosion
A Light for the Nations
The Baltimore Riots
Silence is Golden
Science and Judaism
Birthright Forever
The Whole Picture
Jewish Obligation?
Wisdom and IQ
Divine Justice
The “Chosen People”
Science and Judaism
Why Do Good People Suffer?
Mitzvah Parallels
Angels and Afterlife
Noachide Laws
The Kindness of Human Diversity
Have a question?
 
Gateways - Your Key to Jewish Continuity

AskTheRabbi.org is a service of the Gateways Organization © 2024
Technical problems? Please contact the AskTheRabbi Support team