Advanced Search

Don’t Pass the Shovel


Question:

At a burial why do we put the shovel back into the ground after placing some earth into the grave with it rather than handing it on to the next person who will shovel earth into the grave?



AskTheRabbi.org answered:

This is one of many widespread customs that we find at Jewish burials. In fact I was recently at a funeral and a young couple was attending an Orthodox one for the first time. They were friends of the person who passed, of blessed memory. This is one of the questions they asked me during the service. A day later they called to tell me how the recent events and ceremony inspired them to learn more about their Jewish heritage.

Regarding the custom of placing the shovel on the ground instead of handing it to the person next in line who is waiting to also fulfill the special mitzvah of burial, I have seen two reasons in a book and heard a third reason from a rabbi in Jerusalem. One reason is that on the day a person is buried it is not considered correct behavior to pass something to another. Why not? One of the messages to the participants of a funeral is to understand that at the time of death we are all equal. Passing the shovel directly to the next person could be seen as type of dominance over the receiver. Placing the spade into the earth amplifies the idea of equality.

A second reason is that the time of the burial is a time of great anguish, and to pass the shovel from one to the other would be symbolic of passing the anguish. A third reason which I heard is somewhat similar, yet different. If one passes the shovel into the hand of another person he is in effect saying, “Bury him!” It shows a lack of sensitivity to the recipient of the shovel, and the recipient might even see it as symbolic gesture that he is being told he is a “burier” – which can be very unnerving.

May we all know and share only happy occasions and soon live to see the fulfillment of the prophetic statement that God will “swallow up death in victory; and … wipe away tears from all faces.” (Isaiah 25:8)


Similar Questions
Life Cycle > Death and Mourning
120
Funeral Etiquette
Yahrzeit Date
Getting Married at Funeral Home
Wreaths on Graves
What is Sitting Shiva?
Kaddish for a Friend
Unfortunate Family Event
Jewish Cemetery
A Day to Remember
Parent Requesting Cremation
Burial and Cremation
Kaddish
How Long is Kaddish Said?
Cremation (2)
Reincarnation
Miscarriages
Euthanasia
What Happens After Death?
Tattoo and Burial
Tattoo Taboo
Why Say Kaddish?
Honoring a Parent
Sitting Shiva for a Baby
Learning the Laws of Mourning for Someone Who is Still Alive
Organ Donation
Bon Voyage
Jewish Cemetary
Longevity Limits
Visiting Gravesite
Explaining Death to a Child
Cleaning Gravestones
Visiting a Mourner
Quality of Life
When does Sitting Shiva End?
The “Kaddish” Prayer
Who Says Kaddish, How Long?
Sitting Shiva for Half Sibling
Dealing with Death
Travelling for Yahrzeit
Making a Monument
Of Blessed Memory
Perpetuating a Loved One
Mourner Leading Prayer Services
A Letter to Beyond
Cremation
The Last Day of Mourning
Jewish Burial
Attending Engagement During Mourning
My Child's Wedding During Mourning
Expressing Condolences
Tombstone Date
Covering Mirrors During Week of Mourning
Another World: More Than Meets the Eye
Unveiling
The Comforting Visit
Close to Death
Placing Stones on Graves
A Reality Check
Services in a House of Mourning
The More Important Mitzvah
Where Do We Go When We Die?
Have a question?
 
Gateways - Your Key to Jewish Continuity

AskTheRabbi.org is a service of the Gateways Organization © 2024
Technical problems? Please contact the AskTheRabbi Support team