Advanced Search

Pharaoh’s Heart


Question:

Why would a just God harden Pharaoh’s heart and take away his freedom to choose whether to let the Children of Israel go or not?



AskTheRabbi.org answered:

Good question. Here are two answers to your question. Maimonides writes that it was a punishment for not heeding the previous warnings and not freeing the Jewish slaves. Therefore, Pharaoh lost his right to free will and became a puppet in the hand of God.

Another answer is very different and esoteric. It was not a punishment, but rather a way to balance his thinking and give him a fair chance to make the correct decision. Without a ‘hardened heart’ he certainly would have freed the Jewish slaves after suffering the previous plagues. It was a no brainer decision that he’d make and would not even be a real “choice”. By hardening Pharaoh’s heart, God actually gave back to Pharaoh his free will to react as he really wanted rather than reacting due to being overpowered by the might of God.

That is to say that God didn't force Pharaoh to say "No." He simply gave Pharaoh the opportunity to do so. Nothing but his own stubbornness stopped Pharaoh from repenting. The essence of the second idea is that without the hardening of the heart Pharaoh would have thrown the Jewish People out immediately. Not because he believed that God was right but only because he knew that God was infinitely stronger than him.


Similar Questions
History > Exodus
Mount Sinai
Archaeological Evidence for the Exodus
Which Sea Did the Israelites Cross?
Number of Jews in Exodus
600,000 Jewish Souls
Archaeology and Torah
The Red Sea
First Mitzva
Moses not a Kohen
Numbers of Jews in Exodus
Percentage of Jews in Exodus
Mount Sinai's Names
Dying in the Desert
Exodus – When?
Pharaoh and the Plague Paradox
Why Egypt?
Moshe (Moses)
The Burning Bush
Mount Sinai's Location
One Nation, Under God
How Many Left?
Meat in the Desert
Let My People Go
Why Eat Only Manna?
Philosophy > Free Will
Jealousy
Courage
"Silver Lining"
Decisions
Persuasion
Enjoyment Without Regret?
Good and Bad
Anger
Destiny
God Help Us
Life's Difficulties
Mystical Experiences
Physical Health
"The Free Will Paradox"
A Balancing Act
Misplaced Spirituality
To Tell the Truth
Charity Begins with Justice
Being Tested
Noah's Ark
Responding to Insults
To Compete or Not?
Why Don’t I See Any Miracles?
Hypocrisy?
Choosing a Rabbi
Was I Really “Born This Way”?
Upgraded Me
Love Your Neighbor
Silence is Golden
Making the Grade in Life
Judge Me
Jonah and Suicide
Dealing with Failure
Divine Justice
Freedom of Speech
Have a question?
 
Gateways - Your Key to Jewish Continuity

AskTheRabbi.org is a service of the Gateways Organization © 2024
Technical problems? Please contact the AskTheRabbi Support team