Advanced Search

Birthright and Brothers


Question:

This week's Torah portion (Toldot) says that Esav was starving and sold his birthright to his brother Jacob for a bowl of lentils. I don’t get it. Why didn't Jacob simply give his brother something to eat? Wouldn't that be the brotherly (not to mention humanly decent) thing to do? Thanks in advance.



AskTheRabbi.org answered:

You're asking an excellent question! But interestingly enough, there's no clear indication from the text that Jacob withheld food from Esav.

On the contrary, the verses indicate that Jacob actually did give his brother Esav food immediately when he saw his brother starving. The verse says (Gen. 25:33-34), "He (Esav) sold his birthright to Jacob, and Jacob had (already) given Esav bread and lentils..." According to the rules of Hebrew grammar, "had given" is past perfect, meaning that when Esav sold the birthright for money, Jacob had already given him free food! (Rabbi Yaakov Tzvi Mecklenburg)

But even if we assume that Jacob withheld the food, why would he do that? The Talmud states, "Rabbi Yochanan said: Five sins that wicked one (Esav) transgressed on that day — adultery, murder, heresy, denial of the future resurrection and despising of the birthright."

Jacob knew who his brother was. The birthright included the privilege to lead the family in the service of God. Esav was totally unworthy to serve God. Jacob knew He would desecrate that service. The very fact that Esav sold the birthright showed just how unworthy of it he was. Therefore, Yaakov saw this opportunity as an obligation to relieve Esav of the birthright.


Similar Questions
History > Patriarchs, Matriarchs & Leaders
Leprosy and Slander
Forefather Performing Mitzvot
Noah’s Wife
How Moses Knew Hebrew
Tzippora and Ruth
Moses - Most Humble Man
Rabbinical Movement
Hebron
Moses' Mother
Gaza
Joseph and Faith in God
Rabbi Chaim of Brisk
Sanhedrin
Joshua and Jericho
Abraham's Significance
Judaism’s Ancestry
Friendship
David's Height
A “Great” Name
Our Father and Our Teacher
Apportioning the Land of Israel
Tree of Life
Torah Before Sinai
Abraham Keeping the Commandments
Slow and Steady Wins the Race
The Unknown Tomb of Moses
Abraham, the First Jew
Inauguration Prayer of King Solomon
Ecclesiastes
Sarah - Princess
Sanhedrin II
Song - David Melech Yisrael
The Twelve Tribes
The High Standard of Leadership
King Solomon’s Special Ring
Moshe (Moses)
King David’s Mother
The First Jew
“Inventions”
Jonah and Suicide
The Myth of Moses’ Mountain
Chazal
Twinkle, Twinkle, Like the Stars
Rachel, Rabbi Akiva's Wife
Have a question?
 
Gateways - Your Key to Jewish Continuity

AskTheRabbi.org is a service of the Gateways Organization © 2024
Technical problems? Please contact the AskTheRabbi Support team