Advanced Search

Believing is Believing


Question:

Is there a mitzvah to believe in God? If so, how can a person be commanded to believe? Either a person does or doesn’t. Thanks.



AskTheRabbi.org answered:

Yes, Maimonides writes: “The first mitzvah is His command to us to believe in the Divinity. That is, that there is a transcendent essence which is the cause of everything that exists. "I am the Lord your God (Ex. 20:2)" is a statement of this command...” This is actually the first of the “Ten Commandments”.

You ask: "What is the point of such a commandment? Either you believe or you don't. If you do believe, then everything else will follow; but if you don't, who is commanding you to believe?"

I’ll even strengthen your question. How can God command the average person to believe something that a genius the likes of Aristotle chose not to believe?

In his response to these questions, Rabbi Elchanan Wasserman points to an intriguing expression in the Torah: "Do not follow the desires of your heart (Num. 15:39)".

Our Talmudic Sages comment that this verse warns us not to stray from our belief in God. Rabbi Wasserman asks, “Why the heart? Why not the mind? Why don't our Sages tell us not to make the intellectual mistake of heresy? What does the heart have to do with not believing?”

He answers that belief in God is Mankind's "natural condition." In lieu of external influences, every person would cling to this faith, and heresy would not exist. However, there are countless distractions and provocative challenges to our moral integrity. These opportunities for forbidden pleasures act as a bribe to our intellect. Suddenly our judgment becomes blurred, and we find ourselves looking to justify the illicit behavior. Not far down that path is the porthole to disbelief. The Torah's command not to follow the desires of our heart is a warning to not take the bribe offered by temptation, because its end is in apostasy.

Conversely, when the Torah commands us to believe in God, it is commanding us to nurture our natural sense of the Divine — to bolster the foundation of our relationship with God.


Similar Questions
God > Belief
Belief in God
Let Us Make Man
Finding God
Belief
Proof of God and Torah
Commandment to Believe in God
Joseph and Faith in God
Is there only One God?
Proof of God's Existence
God - Male or Female
Face of God
A Need for Answers
Principles of the Jewish Faith
God's Existence
Principle of Faith: The Existence of God
Principle of Faith: The Unity of God
Principle of Faith: God is Not Corporeal
Searching for God
Observance Without (Total) Belief
One Nation, Under God
Martial Arts and Special Forces
Hear O Israel …
Mitzvot > Belief
Commandment to Believe in God
Principles of the Jewish Faith
Resurrection
Principle of Faith: The Existence of God
Principle of Faith: The Unity of God
Principle of Faith: God is Not Corporeal
Observance Without (Total) Belief
One Nation, Under God
Philosophy > Misc.
Dreams
Ghosts
Planning the Future
Animal Souls?
Art
Never Too Late
Shabbat Nachamu
A National Holiday and National Identity
The Logic of the Illogical
Animal Heaven
Environmental Protection
Dream Interpretation
Day of Rest
Wine in Judaism
Animal Soul?
Papal Purpose Perspective
Love on Demand
The Fear Factor
Yankee's Fan
The Need for Poverty
Music in Judaism
Miracles
A “Safe House” Without Terrorism
Truth
Have a question?
 
Gateways - Your Key to Jewish Continuity

AskTheRabbi.org is a service of the Gateways Organization © 2024
Technical problems? Please contact the AskTheRabbi Support team