Advanced Search

The Flood and the Fish


Question:

Hi Rabbi. With all the current news of the tragic flooding in Texas as a result of Hurricane Harvey, it reminds me of the Great Flood at the time of Noah, and a question popped into my head: What happened to the fish in that Biblical flood? Thanks!



AskTheRabbi.org answered:

Very interesting question! Before I answer it, allow me to express condolences, prayers and sincere wishes for a complete and speedy recovery to all who are affected by this horrific natural disaster.

Regarding the fish in the Biblical flood, we are taught that the various types of fish survived the flood — despite the fact that we are also taught that the flood water was scalding hot.

This apparently contradictory information is resolved by Nachmanides (Rabbi Moshe ben Nachman 1194-1270, Spain and Israel). He gives two possible answers in his commentary to Gen. 7:23.

  • The scalding water was in streams (like the Gulf Stream) above the continents only.
  • Even if the boiling water was in the oceans, it would rise to the top (because heat rises) and the fish could escape to the depths for the 40 days.

Although the second answer does not seem to explain how sea mammals such as whales and dolphins who come to the surface to breathe were saved, one might suggest that Noah took these specific species onto his Ark.

Thank you for your fascinating question, and let us hope that our own “flood” of love and kindness will one day soon engulf the globe, and that “the earth will be full of Godly knowledge, just as the waters cover the ocean.” (Isaiah 11:9)


Similar Questions
History > Misc.
The Ten Commandments
Torah as History Book?
Garden of Eden - Adam and Eve
Died Without Sin
Book of Cures
King David’s Family Tree
Second Temple Destruction
Flag of the Tribe of Menasheh
Noah’s Wife
What are the Nephilim?
Twelve Tribe Descendants
Star of David - Magen David
Aliya after 1948
Origin of the Word Jew
First Jews in the US
Mark of Cain
The Age of Judaism
Nations
A Round-Trip to Sinai
Noah's Ark
The Rainbow Reminder
The Sin of the Ten Spies
Long Lives
Forty and the Flood
Lot's Wife
Sanhedrin Cases
The Star and Shield of David
Hammurabi vis-à-vis Torah
Polish Legislation and Holocaust Denial
Names of Months
A Symbol from Mt. Sinai
Cain's and Abel's Twin Sisters
Korach and Moses
Died Without Sin
Rainbows
Black Death
What Year Is It?
Famous Converts
Noah’s Ark’s Ecosystem
Moses' Sons
Protection During Festivals
Pre-Shabbat Siren
Revolutionary War and Jewish Patriotism
Miscellaneous > World Events
Earthquakes
The Russian Meteorite: a “Natural” Phenomenon?
The President and Proverbs
Purim and Anti-Semitism
Forty and the Flood
Polish Legislation and Holocaust Denial
The Baltimore Riots
A “Safe House” Without Terrorism
The Nepal Earthquake
Eclipses: Physics or Metaphysics?
Revolutionary War and Jewish Patriotism
Have a question?
 
Gateways - Your Key to Jewish Continuity

AskTheRabbi.org is a service of the Gateways Organization © 2022
Technical problems? Please contact the AskTheRabbi Support team