Advanced Search

Doing and Understanding


Question:

If a person does a mitzvah but doesn’t have 100% belief that there is a God or if the Torah is true — does the mitzvah have any value?



AskTheRabbi.org answered:

First of all, there are many, many levels of belief, and often even a very low level can produce a lot of benefit, and make mitzvah observance worth something.

Secondly, in terms of negative commandments, the "Thou shalt nots," if a person refrains even for the wrong reasons, still he is refraining and not bringing all kinds of negative consequences onto himself and others.

In my experience a lack of belief is often related to a lack of a proper Jewish, Torah education. Without learning about our wonderful heritage it’s “difficult” to make an informed decision about belief. How can one believe or not believe something that one hasn’t tried to study and understand as much as possible?

If there is a basic belief in God, just a lack of understanding of the necessity of the mitzvah, then performance with trust in God that it is the right thing is really performance on a high level. The very acceptance of mitzvot by the Jewish people at Sinai was with the condition "Na'aseh v'nishma" ("We will do and we will understand"), meaning that we will do even before we understand.

True, a person should try to understand, and certainly an understanding of the background and fullness of the mitzvah will create a deepened satisfaction in mitzvah performance. This usually comes with increased Torah study. Lack of this understanding, however, does not take away from the fulfillment of the mitzvot.


Similar Questions
Mitzvot > Observance
Circumcision on the Eighth Day
Changing a Character Trait
Relationships and Commandments
Easy to be Jewish?
Love Your Neighbor
Hypocrisy?
Friends
Anger
Purpose of Commandments
Kosher Speech
A Sabbath Candle
Rituals and Kindness
Step-by-Step
Keeping the Mitzvot
Self Advancement and Teaching Others
Partial Observance of Mitzvot
Torah Study and Jewish Obervance at University
Am I a Bad Jew?
Why Keep the Mitzvot?
May One Be Addicted to the Observance of Mitzvot?
The Mitzvah System
Father's and Mother's Day
Tithing
Shabbat and Holiday Times
Becoming a Better Person
Treat it Like Your Friend
Charity Begins with Justice
The Ladder of Righteousness
A Time to Return
Mitzvah Methodology
Testing the Waters
Choosing a Rabbi
Observance Without (Total) Belief
Tithing of Money
Mother’s Day — 365 Days a Year
Being Fruitful
Judge Me
Jewish Obligation?
A Meaningful Mitzvah
Good Intentions and Good Results
Have a question?
 
Gateways - Your Key to Jewish Continuity

AskTheRabbi.org is a service of the Gateways Organization © 2024
Technical problems? Please contact the AskTheRabbi Support team