Advanced Search

Decrees and Sufficient Time for the Jews to Save Themselves

Josh of Durham, NC asked:

Regarding Purim, it struck me as somewhat strange that the decree to kill the Jews would be issued almost an entire year before it was to be carried out...wouldn't this have given the Jews time to escape or ready themselves, regardless of a counter-order? answered:

Haman made two decrees. The first was to destroy the entire Jewish People. The second was that everyone should be ready and prepared for something special on the 13th of Adar. The decree that the Jews should be killed was secret. The Vilna Gaon explains that the reason that Haman kept the first decree secret was in order to prevent the Jews from escaping in any way.

  • Esther 3:13,14
  • Vilna Gaon, commentary to Megillat Esther

Similar Questions
Holidays > Purim
Purim – A Physical Celebration
Purim – A “Hidden” Miracle
The Purim Story
Iran – Then and Now
Megillah by Phone
Why Do We Make Noise Only for Haman?
Why No Hallel on Purim?
Walled Cities and Shushan Purim
Spelling in the Megillah
Sending Gifts of Food
Hamantaschen on Purim
Masquerading on Purim
Esther's Age
Work and Payment on Purim
What Became of Esther?
Eating Seeds on Purim
Mordechai's Relationship with Esther
Da'at Torah
Wearing Costumes on Purim
Small & Large Letters in Haman's Sons' Names
Celebrating While So Many Died
Bowing down
Kosher Alcoholic Drinks
Esther's Marrying a Non-Jew
Who is Amalek?
Purim and Unity
Purim, Persia and Iran
The Shabbat Before Purim
Parashat Zachor
Preparing for Purim
Purim and Anti-Semitism
Laws and Customs of Purim
A Month when Opposites Detract
Adar Month of Happiness and Laughter
“Remembering” Purim on Shabbat
The Thirteenth Month
The Story of Purim
Purim - Unity of the Jewish People
Have a question?
Gateways - Your Key to Jewish Continuity is a service of the Gateways Organization © 2022
Technical problems? Please contact the AskTheRabbi Support team